What is Test Coverage and How to Plan for It?

If you’ve ever looked into the world of software quality assurance you’ve probably stumbled across the term “test coverage”. But what is test coverage and why is it important? Put simply, test coverage is how much of a product's source code is executed in a test run. The higher the coverage, the lower the chance of undetected bugs popping up in your code and into production.

However, test coverage is more than just a numbers game. It’s a key indicator of how well your tests are exploring the different paths and behaviors of your application. In this blog post, we’ll break down what test coverage entails, why it’s essential for delivering reliable software, and how teams can approach it effectively.

How to determine test coverage needs

There are various ways to plan and calculate test coverage. Most teams rely on four common models to ensure test coverage. Developers often combine these models with their product knowledge to prioritize test scenarios that will provide the most meaningful and valuable test coverage.

1. Workflow coverage. Also known as path coverage, this approach focuses on tracking the different paths users take through an application. It is great for identifying anomalies when applications interact with different systems outside the developer’s team’s direct control.

2. Functionality coverage. Also known as product coverage, this model focuses on how users interact with an application’s UI to assess different input/output combinations. Also, it ensures that various functionalities are thoroughly exercised, helping to identify coverage gaps in the user experience.

3. Requirements coverage. This type of test coverage verifies if an application meets the specified requirements and user expectations. It helps ensure that developers are aligned with business goals and working to meet commitments made to users.

4. Risk coverage. This model helps to identify potential risks to both the business and its customers. By prioritizing test scenarios based on risk, teams can focus on areas that pose the greatest threat if left untested. 

These models often overlap and are best used in combination. It’s important to note that these are four of the most common models and there are additional test coverage models that teams can use and adapt to their specific needs.

How to evaluate the test coverage needs for your organization

It’s important to understand what your organization needs before you allocate resources for software testing. Attempting to test everything can lead to lengthy development cycles and delayed releases, so prioritizing is key. Here’s how to evaluate your test coverage needs effectively.

• Risk assessment. Evaluate the potential risks associated with your software. High-risk areas might include financial transactions, user data handling, or critical business logic. These typically require more comprehensive testing and higher coverage, as they have the greatest potential to impact the business or users if they fail.
• Project complexity. The more complex your systems are, the greater the need for extensive test coverage. Consider the number of modules, third-party integrations, and the overall architecture complexity.
• Team capabilities. Take into account your team's skills and expertise. A more experienced team might achieve effective coverage with less extensive testing, while a less experienced team might need broader coverage to catch potential issues.
• Resource constraints. Consider your budget, time, and available tools. These factors will influence the extent of coverage you can realistically achieve. Prioritize critical areas if resources are limited.
• Code stability. Keep in mind that  code that undergoes frequent changes may require higher coverage to catch regression bugs. In contrast, stable parts of the codebase may require less frequent or in-depth testing, allowing you to allocate resources more efficiently.
• User impact. Focus on features and functionality that directly impact user experience or business operations. These often warrant higher coverage.
• Historical data analysis. Review past bug reports, previous test results, and customer feedback. Areas that have been problematic in the past may benefit from increased coverage.
• Automated vs. manual testing. Determine which areas are best suited for automated testing (e.g., repetitive tasks, regression testing) and which require manual testing (e.g., usability testing, exploratory testing). A combination of both can help optimize your test coverage strategy.

Read our case study: UJET Improves QA Processes and Ensures Smoother Releases With TestDevLab

Remember, the goal isn't necessarily to achieve 100% coverage, but to have confidence in your software's quality and reliability. Tailor your test coverage approach to fit your organization's specific needs and constraints for the most effective results.

Balancing quantity and quality

It is important to balance your quantitative testing with your qualitative testing to ensure test coverage addresses all aspects of an application. Quantitative models, like code coverage and performance coverage, can provide valuable insights into application health. However, focusing on numbers alone can overlook critical issues. To achieve well-rounded test coverage, we’ve got three key ingredients to help you get it right:

Key ingredients for effective test coverage

1. In-depth knowledge of the application

A deep understanding of the application’s architecture, features, and functionality allows testers to focus on areas that are most prone to errors or critical to business operations.

2. Familiarity with typical user interactions

Knowing how users typically interact with your application helps ensure that your testing reflects real-world scenarios, covering the most common workflows and user journeys.

3. Experience in planning tests for adequate coverage

Skill in test planning is essential to balance the depth of test coverage. Experienced testers can prioritize high-risk areas while ensuring comprehensive coverage without unnecessary over-testing.

Final thoughts

Achieving effective test coverage requires a strategic blend of quantitative and qualitative testing, in-depth knowledge about the application, and a thorough understanding of user behavior. By focusing on high-risk areas, balancing metrics with real-world scenarios, and planning for adequate coverage, you can safeguard your software’s quality and reliability. However, getting this balance right can be challenging, and that's where expert QA support makes all the difference.

Ready to ensure comprehensive test coverage for your software? Our QA services are designed to help businesses achieve optimal test coverage, minimize risks, and deliver high-quality products. Whether you're dealing with complex systems or looking to improve efficiency, our experienced team is here to guide you through every stage of the process. Get in touch with us and let us help you build more reliable, bug-free software.